All posted by
Gurthang:
Quote:
Estel, I do have a question for you. In this post:
Quote:
Originally Posted by The Only Real Estel
Once more on gifted roles: Subtle hints would be nice. If you think you are incapable of hinting subtlely, don't do it; but if you can drop a small hint or two it would be extremely helpful. Although I should say I've got two of the gifted roles 95% worked out (excluding wolves of course).
It sounds like you haven't seen any hints from the Seer...
|
You'll notice I said I have two gifted roles 95% worked out. One was the seer. I was hoping to get other roles to drop more hints so that I could narrow down my rather wide suspect list. There is, of course, always the chance of a wolf dropping Hunterish hints or something like that, but it would be awfully hard for that wolf to keep it up for very long.
Quote:
...yet in this one:
Quote:
Originally Posted by The Only Real Estel
I don't suspect you I just haven't entirely cleared you yet, I can't be sure of anyone's innocence at the moment except Fea's. And besides, trust can easily be twisted by these wolves. I don't trust just anyone & I don't want anyone to just trust me on Fea or anything else I might find in earlier or later posts. Search for yourself, it's not that difficult - I daresay our seer may be in danger.
You are so certain of Feanor's innocence. Why the switch? I also don't see how you can be 100% sure of anyone being the Seer just yet. I know you probably can't explain too much because it would reveal who you think the Seer is, but could you tell me what you can.
|
As to the 'switch,' I finally got some time to really scour the thread and found what is, in my opinion, quite conclusive evidence.
Now I've got to be choosey here. I'm sorry but I'm not going to expand much because if I accidently give away the identity of the seer I'll lynch myself. You don't see how I can be 100% sure of the Seer just yet? Sir, did you not take that course in Phantomology that was offered in the village not a month ago? It is not as hard as all that, you just need some time to really think things out. To be accurate I am not 100% sure of the seer, only 95%. But the difference between being totally lost & at least knowing one innocent is worth the 5% risk, I think.
I hope you're satisfied because I'm not going into further detail no matter what, find it yourself.
