Uh, should I not be trying to analize what has happened so far,
Bergil? That is what all innocents should be doing, why is that suspicious?
Also:
Quote:
|
well, the cobbler has died, how do we respond to that? i beleive that no wolves would have voted for him, in fact none voted for another person at all. my logic behind this is that wolves want to avoid leaving a trail, and will not vote if they think it won't make them look suspicious, otherwise they'll vote in a way that won't incriminate them.
|
Well, if the wolves want to avoid being suspicious, then the way to do that is certiainly not to
not vote, in my opinion. We have no guarentee that no wolf voted for
Wayne because, of course, none of them could have known he was the Cobbler.
I do agree with you, however, that they would probably want to vote in a way that wouldn't incriminate them.
A few thoughts:
Bergil- suspected
malkatoj &
Fea but
Fea moreso (#22), strongly suspects
Fea (#27), admits possibly over-reacting on
Fea (#34), somewhat iffy sounding logic (to me) surrounding how the wolves would have voted, reaffirms suspicion of
Fea, accuses me of being 'strangely analytical' (#92) Unsure of
Eonwe- wants reasons, not just suspicions (#11), thinks voting is good for leaving trails-backtracks a bit (#13), sounds a little non-commital (#44), goes with a random vote (#52), says
Fea is probably innocent (#74) Unsure of
Feanor of the Peredhil- confusing as usual, but I say we let her logic work for her & I'll say why in a very short while, suspects
malkatoj Likely innocent
Jack (aka Folwren)- half-suspects
Sleepy (#24), suspects their could be a
Kitanna/Gurthang alliance (#30), advises people against voting for
Fea (#46), doesn't vote (interesting) (#49), makes a point about
Sleepy's apparent "wishywashyness" of whatever you want to call it, thinks that
Fea is innocent despite being confusing, that
Eonwe is somewhat suspicious at least &
Bergil is questionable (#78) Not quite sure of
Kitanna- dead but why? did she hit to close to home?
Gurthang- says he thinks the wolves killed someone not associated with them (#61), states that he likes it when everyone votes so there's a trail, says
Fea is still acting suspicious, wants a reason for
Sleepy jumping in with
Fea on
Malkatoj (#73), presses
Sleepy for an answer (#80) Not quite sure of, but likely innocent
Hiriel- Nothing to work with yet
Malkatoj- suspects
Fea for pegging 5 wolves when there are only 3 (#10), supports
Gurthang &
Hiriel (#18), asks
Fea for reasons on her suspicion of
TORE (#21), wants more reasons from
Fea (#70) Unsure of
Rune Son of Bjarne- seems to be rather level headed, voiced suspicions of
me early on, now he voices some suspicion of
Bergil &
Hiriel for not having spoken (although Bergil now has) Probably innocent, not quite sure
Sleepy Ranger- Very suspicious of
Fea (#64), half as suspicious of
Fea now, more suspicous of
malkatoj, has a few doubts of
me, thinks
Gurthang may be sowing seeds of distrust (#72), reiterates that he DID NOT take
my side (#79), now says that
Fea is suspicious as well as
malkatoj (#81), looks a bit suspicious to me some of his later posts Unsure of
Thinlomien- suspicious of
Fea (#63), not much at all to go on