Pheh, I've tried organizing this for a while now. You're just getting a list with my thoughts on people. Deal with it.
Folwren -- Doesn't seem particularly suspicous to me, her somewhat vehement response to Mormegil's was a little strange but while it's worth noting it's not enough to make her outstandly suspicous.
Shelob -- I know myself to be innocent, in response to Saucepan Man having me on his list of "talkative but not particularly outspoken" I'm trying, but I'm fighting a battle against nature and so don't have high hopes of looking anything except "talkative but not particularly outspoken"
Holbytlass -- I don't really see her as being suspicous. I certainly don't understand the proposed Holby-Kath connection.
Meneltarmacil -- Meneltarmacil's being 'shifty'. I certainly still suspect him but can't really get a feel for why. My best example would be that Meneltarmacil says (of Folwren)
Quote:
|
I notice him claiming that Alcarillo is a wolf (but only after the idea was proposed earlier)
|
When Folwren was the first person on DAY 1 to mention Alcarillo as being suspicous.
WaynetheGoblin -- Having dropped most of my suspicions from yesterday (though the teeth comment still strikes me as strange) I notice that Wayne again posts little and specifically parallels his suspicions to those of a well trusted and outspoken person (Saucepan Man, to be more specific)
wilwarin538 -- Not sure how to feel about Wilwarin, the timing on her vote for Bergil could either be innocent-trying-to-avoid-a-tie or werewolf-trying-to-save-werewolf, it depends on whether Alcarillo's innocent or not. And even in that case her vote was early, when a tie wasn't that big a deal. If Alcarillo's guilty I'll need to look closer at her, but elsewise I think she's probably innocent.
Alcarillo -- Definately in a suspicous looking position. In the least I agree his death would likely tell us the most, however beyond his position I see little to suggest he's a werewolf.
Durelin -- Little to work with. Other than his absence today nothing particularly suspicious.
Saucepan Man -- Nothing I've been able to find suggests he's a wolf, though I doubt anything would be there if he were. As to the Phantom-Saucepan Man suggestion, I'm doubting it. It's concievable, I just don't see it. In any case those two are more helpful to keep around, if they're innocent they're a huge help in finding wolves and if one/both are guilty the longer they're around the more of their masterplan we'll be able to see if we lynch them.
Kath -- Very insistant on a few people. I figure it's too dangerous a strategy for a wolf to be using. Not to discount the possibility, her lack of reasons make her suspicious. And while I know she has since answered questions I've not yet had the time to read them carfully, until I do I feel she's worth keeping an eye on but not an immediate danger.
the phantom -- Irksomely suspicous, as always. He hasn't risen in my suspicions though, so as before with The Saucepan Man I feel that even if he is guilty his death would be more useful later.
Azaelia of Willowbottom -- People have brought up good points about her vote and it's implications, but I believe she simply panicked and went with the majority. I know that's what I'd likely do if I looked down and had a minute to vote with no real suspicions.
Cailín -- I haven't found anything particularly suspicous about Cailín. Nothing beyond the natural suspiciousness of being in our village while there are were-creatures running about.
Nilpaurion Felagund -- Hasn't really spoken enough for me to find any reason to suspect him beyond his lack of speaking.
mormegil -- I don't honestly feel that Mormegil is anything but what he appears. I haven't been able to find something to suspect him as he seems to be really helpful (which is potentially reason enough).
Gil-Galad -- Elusive. He doesn't post much (either in quantity or in information) so it's hard really suspect him.
Glirdan -- Beyond his undecidedness (trying to please everyone) I see little reason to suspect Glirdan. I feel like he's probably in much the place I am, suspected because we're not naturally agressive in taking stands yet too talkative to be ignored.
Sorry if I seem a bit short (curt might be better), I'm having scheduling issues with school which have left me ill tempered. This calmed me somewhat though so expect me back shortly once I've had some time to think more on everything that's been said, esp. theories containing more than one person.