[The Saucepan Man]

LMP - both of your suggestions mean that people who voted earlier in the Day for one of the "multiple lynchees" could be out of the game without having done anything wrong simply because someone comes along later and forces a tie. Indeed, this could be used by either side (but most probably one of the werecreatures) as a tactic, albeit a desperate one.

I still say that, in the event of a tie, the lynchee is either randomly chosen or, better still, the person who attracted the first vote out of all those tied.