[Eomer of the Rohirrim]

Aragorn: "It's tough, I know, but one of them is a foul lupine."

Gandalf: "I cannot bear the thought of killing another innocent..."

Aragorn: "Let's think logically. Gimli saved the Witch-King at the expense of Boromir, a known innocent, and look at how that turned out! Why have we kept him alive this long?"

Gandalf: "He's the Cobbler, I'm sure of it!"

Aragorn: "I can't trust you anymore Gandalf. I mean, sure you were the Hunter (and did us a great service in getting rid of the Balrog) but ever since you were resurrected by the Moddess Mithalwen you've appeared a bit dodgy to me..."

Gandalf: "What? Dodgy? How scandalous! I am now suspecting you Aragorn of werewolvery!

Aragorn:" O yea! Suspect me because I suspect you. Way to play the game, old boy."

Éomer: "I'll just tell you now that I'm the Seer and I know for a fact that Gandalf is innocent."

Captain Obvious: "One of us is a werewolf."

Gimli: "I say we kill Legolas."

Everyone else: "Agreed!"



*100 Bonus Points to the person who votes for the Werewolf first. Votes should be in this style: ++the phantom * (it is not compulsory that you vote for the phantom)