I've modified the post above to reflect 6 matches, Fea
Now let us find the criterion:
It is not Barrow-Benefactors, not Top Reputation Givers/Receivers, not people with highest repute or highest post count... m-mm, not members picked by year of joining the forum (eomer 2002, boromir 2004, Underhill 2000, Estelyn 2002, Lhunardawen 2003, Hookbil 2003, we lack 2001 and 2005), not by the first letter of their screennames...
May it be BW stuck names at random, just as we now do, and has chosen funniest titles returned at random?