As with legolas the history of this particular branch is somewhat sketchy !
Quote:
|
Tolkien neglected Legolas' branch of the family terribly, it seems. There is some contradictions between the appendix of LoTR and Tolkien's other writings in Unfinished Tales.
|
I suppose it was tolkien just expanding and finding HIS way around the different aspects of family trees so he made contradictions (it also gives us many interesting posts)
I couldn't attempt an answer to the original question although i would doubt it. We never knew what the prof. was thinkin [img]smilies/smile.gif[/img]