[Kath]

I seem to remember reading somewhere (though I might well be mistaken) that death, or the ability to die, was a gift given to mortal men by Eru.

If this is the case then I was just wondering whether anyone thought that PJ actually pulled this idea off quite well in the films?

For example in the charge of the Rohirrim where they all chant "Death!" as they ride to what they know will be death for a good many of them.

Or when Boromir dies - it is a solemn moment, and sad, but not so much for his death as for his failure in life.

Anyway, would be interested to hear your comments.