Quote:
|
Originally Posted by Lalwendë
And I apologise for not recognising that! I just could not help myself but put in the causal link between the disability and the negative consequences, it's an occupational hazard. And I have to confess, disability issues are a bit of a hobby horse. 
. |
I certainly wasn't intending to attack the disabled - I chose Special Needs ed for my dissertation and more recently have worked in Supported Housing and for a Trust for Adults with Learning Disabilities so it was the last thing on my mind.
However I do think scientific research will raise difficult ethical issues - but may also help some groups - for example reduce the stigma still attached to mental illness. Now I am thinking of Samuel Butler's Erewhon .....
And evil is such and emotive term but what is the alternative? I don't know if II can completely separate the behaviour from the person a la Lord Soper.. but I do think someone who chooses "an evil path" is vastly more culpable than someone whose path has been forced by their genetic make up.
It isn't easy and I can understand why Tolkien had such trouble with the orcs....
I would expand, but I know that my own examples of evil are likely to offend at least one contributor so I think I will leave it there....