another twist, I know, but seeing as I resurrected this thread I'm gonna give it a go.
Kuruharan
Quote:
|
You must take into account that Frodo himself failed in the end.
|
I always get angry when someone says this. I know there are countless threads on this, but I can't let it stand.
Q1. What was the Quest?
A1. To defeat Sauron by destroying the Ring.
Q2. Was the Ring destroyed?
A2. Yes
Q3. Was the Quest a success?
A3. Yes
Q4. Did Frodo, by his compassion for keeping Gollum alive, receive Redemption?
A4. Yes
Q5. Does it matter that Frodo did not actually throw the Ring in the Lava?
A5. No
Q6. Did Frodo Fail in the Quest to destroy the Ring
A6.
No.
...
Sound of second can of worms opening on this thread.