[QUOTE]/
I was wondering, what do you think would have happened in the Legenduim if Beren had not been killed when he got the Silmaril from Melkor. If he had lived out his life as a normal person with an Evish wife. What do you think would have happened at the end of his life to himself and Luthien. Do you think that maybe they would have ended up like Idril and Tuor? Or maybe Luthien would have stilled died with him and everything that happened would have stilled happen only in a different way?/[QUOTE]
tHEN the whole history of Beleriand could be altered.
Luthien and Beren will live at Doriath with the Sil, no Feanorean or Dwarf would assail em, Thingol won't die, Melian will stay and the Girdle thing will remain, protecting Doriath. Bern will die a natural death at a ripe old age, but Luthien won't follow cos her mom, dad, and son're still there. The Sil will remain hidden. All Elf-kingdoms would fall and their remnants will flee to Doriath, and therefore increase its military potential. Sooner or later Morgy will attack them and destroy the Elves. Earendil would not reach Valinor cos the Sil's still there, and he will end up lost. The Valar would not end up in time to save ME, and Morgy will reign.
