Quote:
|
Originally Posted by radagastly
Gandalf the WHITE , on the other hand, was indeed merely "clothed" in human form ...
|
If this was the case, how come Pippin was able to take the Palantir of Orthanc from him while he slept? If he was merely "clothed" rather than incarnate, he would have no need of sleep. And I believe that he is referred to as eating in Minas Tirith too.
Based on this, I think that
Lhuna is right. Gandalf the White was just as much incarnate as Gandalf the Grey.