Hummm....lets see...Definatly keep Merry and Pippin for laughs, also Legolas, because I will need to use his hair products! I would want to get rid of 8 of the 9 nazgul...you never know when you are going to need one, but nine of them is way to much!! They could also take their big bird thingys with them. Lets see who else...Boromir because he dies in the end anyway and Gandalf, but his pointy hat would have to stay!
