|
Hi Saucepan Man, I was refering to Luthien and Arwen after they had made their choice, by their choice they are barred. No mortal may set foot in the Undying Lands against the will of Eru, even Frodo, Bilbo and Sam are only allowed a far as Tol Erresea, but you are right, for we do not know if Eru permitted Mithrellas in or not. It is one of those nice loose ends that Tolkien left dangling, that allows us to
question
|