Ok I agree with a lot of you.
Like Orlando, I mean don't get me wrong he is hot but he just doesn't strike me as elvish more like a mortal. He just wasn't what I invisoned Legolas. 5.5/10
John Noble was ok
I thought he really had the venom in his voice but some things made me think twice about him. In ROTK, when faramir was brought to Minas Tirith He mad it seem like Denethor was really sad about his son when in the book I got the impression that he was more sad that his family would no longer be stewards of Gondor. 8/10
Liv Tyler.
Now this really isn't her fault but I just can't get over it. In the book Arwen wasn't mentioned very much, They gave her more credit than I think she should of had. But I really didn't think she did all that good in the movie not including what I just mentioned. 5/10
well I really don't have time for more.