Quote:
|
Originally Posted by Essex
So what about his narration back at Bag End? That was beautifully delivered and gets me every time I hear it.
Does anyone here except for me and the Saucepan Man actually like these movies?
|
I love these movies. As I've said elsewhere, they are some of the best Tolkien fanfiction ever produced, and have rekindled interest in many, and introduced Tolkien to many who would not otherwise have landed in Middle-Earth at all. They do deviate from the books, etc etc, but given their positive worldwide Tolkien impact I can 'forgive' much. I think they are mostly superb as they stand, and deserved all eleven oscars, etc.
And yes, the narration at Bag End is wonderful-- to me, proof that more of Frodo should have been heard as well as seen. That is my one real complaint about the movies as a whole: that
Frodo was dumbed down.
Otherwise, they are magnificent.