Best Looking: Aragorn
Nicest Eyes: Arwen
Most Likely to commit suicide: Gollum - if he hadn't fallen in
Best Creature to ride: Shall I be naughty with this answer? Nah, maybe next time.
Shadowfax
Cutest Couple: Eowyn and Faramir
Most Athletic: Aragorn
Best Musically inclined: Tom Bombadil
Nicest Car(oops, I mean horse): Gandalf
Nicest Hair: Legolas
Shyest: Faramir
Most Manipulative: The Ring
Most likely to kill PJ because they got screwed when he made the movie: Glorfindel, Arwen or Tom Bombadil