You have made good observations, and thanks, Estelyn, for the link, it's quite an interesting thread! But you haven't really answered my questions. Or maybe I didn't make myself clear.
I assume we all agree that weather has some effect on our moods. If it's raining cats and dogs, you might feel a little blue (at least in case you don't actually love rain). So a proper weater may enhance a scene's emotionalism. On the other hand, it's the actors' performances (as well as the music) that can evoke the viewer's feelings.
From your posts I can get the feeling that you really don't prefer the "Disney-style". Ok, neither do I. So, perhaps it creates nice tension into a scene if the setting and surroundings aren't conservative.
Quote:
|
I have the idea that it should have been misty when Boromir died
|
So would you like to have changed that part in FotR or do you think the sunshine worked well too?