[Boromir88]

Another thing that I now think of is PJ just likes to leave people. I don't know if it's for some emotional climax. But ok, Merry and Pippin are in Fangorn Forest, 1,000's of miles from home and Treebeard just says, "ok go home little shirelings, find your way eventhough you are in some unfamiliar place in the middle of nowhere." Same with Frodo and Sam, "ya we are in the Middle of Mordor, go home Sam, also you'll have to do it with no food since you ate it all(another problem in the movie how the hell do these hobbits survive months with no food, for the fact that it took them weeks to climb the slope of mount doom, and they do it with in a matter of seconds) but you'll find your way home eventhough we couldn't find our way through Emyn Muil." Heck, atleast Tolkien addressed the problem of food, something a lot of writers I think forget.

Nightknight, just for the info, that "soldier" is the made up lieutenant of Faramir, Madril. Which I happen to like the made up Madril, much better then the made up Lurtz. I mean I just love how the big, hairy, demented, orc guy (yes I know that's supposed to be Gothmog, but I like big, hairy, demented, orc guy better) stabs him with a spear in ROTK. But, I agree I would much rather see Beregond, Imrahil, Elladan or Elrohir then some made up captain or immortal orc fellow. And I've actually speculated that PJ would be much better as Forlong then some Corsair Captain, but I guess he couldn't stand being called "Forlong the fat."

You'll have to excuse me, once I get to complaining about all the problems of the movie I can't stop, no matter how bad it might seem though I still love em.