Quote:
|
I have always found it interesting that despite the Elves' immortality, they were unable, in Beleriand at least, to form a stable coalition with consistent membership. However, to say that the High King was merely ceremonial is a little inaccurate; some of the holders of such a title held it for a considerable time. Some of the leaguers of Angband were of great length.
|
You're right, but the "High King" (Noldor) was never able to get his way (do what he wanted) in regards to all of the Kingdoms under his rule. Ex. (Fëanor, Fingolfin)
Quote:
|
I do agree that the high-kingship of the Eldar/Noldor was bordering on nominal.[ Although Elwe's was far more potent than others]. They seemingly had the opwer to summon councils and were also probably arbitrators of disputes. The seemmed however to need something of a consensus to lead.
|
This is very close to what I think.
Wow, to have both Lindil, Aiwendil and Rimbaud post in one of my threads. I'm honored.