[InklingElf]

Originally Posted by Boromir88

Besides the visual inconsistencies (being discussed in another thread) there were a few "hearing inconsistencies" I noticed. One being when in ROTK, Faramir asks his father "you wish that our lives had been switched, that Boromir had lived..etc," Denethor "Yes, I wish that." Then, I ask, why in TTT Extended Edition did Denethor tell Boromir to go to Rivendell? First of it was totally opposite from the book, second why send Boromir? Was this PJ just trying to show Denethor's early "craziness" or was it that PJ just kind of forgot the script of TTT? The other one I could think of was when Pippin had just looked into the Palantir and Gandalf decided to ride to Minas Tirith. Gandalf said "it's 3 days as the nazgul flies...etc." First it took Gandalf and Pippin 3 days to get there just riding, so that would me the nazgul flying would definately take less. If there are any others anyone noticed, please share them.

1)Doesn't the fact that Denethor sends Boromir to an important council at Rivendell make it logical that he is considered the 'Alpha-son'?

2)Shadowfax is really fast. hahahahahaha

Originally Posted by Gurthang

As far as the 'nazgul flies', he just meant in a straight path. When we say fifty miles as the crow flies, we mean fifty miles straight there. But, alas, roads don't always take us where we straight to where want to go(sometimes quite the opposite ), so it invarialbe takes more than fifty miles to reach our destination. Gandalf was simply stating 'It'll take us three days going straight there, provided no sidetracking or pitstops'.