Look the whole scene was stupid. I mean it never happened in the book, and I'll grant artistic license if and only if it can be backed up by proof. Since there is now an entire thread on the discrepancies of the scene, proof seems pretty much non-existant. Gollum takes hold of an elven leaf and crumbles the bread onto Sam whilst making enough noise to wake the dead. The crumbs had all fallen off Sam's jacket before Gollum pointed them out.
I really don't like that scene but I'm sorry if I just turned into crazy obssessed fanatic.
__________________
“If more of us valued food and cheer and song above hoarded gold, it would be a merrier world.”
|