[Saraphim]

Thanks, symestreem. That was really bothering me.

I have a question. Does being half-elf constitute having the 'choice', like Luthien, or is it that one of thier parentswas human and one was an elf, like Earendil? But then again, Earendil had the choice too.

I'm glad Tolkien didn't make things too difficult for his fans.

(Kidding. If it wasn't so complicated, it wouldn't be as fun to talk about.)