Quote:
|
If they were 'stopped' by the Music from acting, then that would mean that the Noldor were meant to go to ME - though probably not in the way they did - & that they were meant to hold Morgoth at bay till the Valar could act effectively against Morgoth - which would mean that the Noldor's 'sin' is not in leaving Valinor - in fact they should have gone - which would mean the Valar were wrong to try & stop them.
|
Well, that's pretty much what I have always believed, though I don't exactly think that the music "stopped" the Valar and made it so they
couldn't have acted differently. I think the music just foretold that they
wouldn't act differently than they did.