Either of them should be correct.
If you're looking at this moment:
Quote:
|
He had a half-eaten fish in his mouth and another in his hand.
|
Then it's Firefoot's.
However,
If you're looking at this moment:
Quote:
|
(he still clutched one in his hand)
|
Then Thorongil has it.
I don't mean to insult you or anything Luthien-elvenprincess, but I could find no other instance where the it is stated the number of fish in Golllum's possession after Henneth Annûn.
Namarie.