[dancing spawn of ungoliant]

I think that the Black Gate scene was wonderful! Sure it included some "cheesy" lines but to me they are just fine and dramatic if I don't think that they're lame. Actually I enjoyed Aragorn's speech and that "For Frodo" line was very touching!

I disliked the "let's see if that mighty troll kills Aragorn before Frodo destroys the ring" scene but the overall impression of the battle was great!

Did you notice that when "the lighthouse of Morodor" crushed down, also the towers at the black gate collapsed? Why? All that was made by Sauron and the ring should have broken then but the towers weren't made by Sauron!