Overall I thought it was very good. My main criticisms centre around Theoden's death (lack of Eomer, lack of dismay, lack of tears), Aragorn's arrival to the Pellenor (basically just coming in the back door, wasn't it?) and, of course, the ridiculous Frodo/Sam/Gollum sequence where Frodo sends Sam away (why? really, why?)<P>But generally I liked it very much, especially the events after the destruction of the Ring. Tears in my eyes.
__________________
Los Ingobernables de Harlond
|