The Barrow-Downs Discussion Forum - View Single Post - Scene(s) you most want to see (done right) in RotK

Shire Flower · 11-26-2003, 02:49 AM

I want to see the suspenseful Morgul Vale scene when Frodo sees the Witch King at the head of the army and is tempted to put on the ring. It would be cool if it was done exactly like in the book, with Frodo having a flashback to Weathertop when he sees the Witch King.... the struggle with the ring.... and when he breaks down in tears because he thinks Faramir and his men are going to die (as well as everyone else in Middle Earth).<P>I would also like to see Sam contemplating suicide when he thinks Frodo is dead. I hope those scenes show the despair Sam is feeling and put the viewer in his shoes, err, hairy feet. <P>Eowyn and Merry killing the Witch King... I hope that scene is done really well, and the dialogue true to the book. I wonder how/if they will show the ringwraith's sudden sense of doubt when he discovers Eowyn is a woman.<P>I hope that Sam's vision of everything blowing up after the ring is destroyed is sufficently dramatic. It's an awesome grand finale to the quest!

11-26-2003, 02:49 AM	#6
Shire Flower Pile O'Bones Join Date: Jul 2003 Posts: 25	I want to see the suspenseful Morgul Vale scene when Frodo sees the Witch King at the head of the army and is tempted to put on the ring. It would be cool if it was done exactly like in the book, with Frodo having a flashback to Weathertop when he sees the Witch King.... the struggle with the ring.... and when he breaks down in tears because he thinks Faramir and his men are going to die (as well as everyone else in Middle Earth).<P>I would also like to see Sam contemplating suicide when he thinks Frodo is dead. I hope those scenes show the despair Sam is feeling and put the viewer in his shoes, err, hairy feet. <P>Eowyn and Merry killing the Witch King... I hope that scene is done really well, and the dialogue true to the book. I wonder how/if they will show the ringwraith's sudden sense of doubt when he discovers Eowyn is a woman.<P>I hope that Sam's vision of everything blowing up after the ring is destroyed is sufficently dramatic. It's an awesome grand finale to the quest!