The Barrow-Downs Discussion Forum - View Single Post

Iarwain · 06-20-2003, 08:33 PM

Presuming that a fourth film whose story takes place after the War of the Ring will be produced, these are my thoughts:1. If they make a fourth film, I believe it's plot will circulate around the Dagor Dagorath. 2. The tale of the Dagor Dagorath was not written by Tolkien. This leaves it to be invented by three people that I do not consider at all to be trustworthy in creating a new installment for the tale of middle earth.3. I cringe at the thought of PJ, Philly, and Franny ruining a fine possibility for an ending to the masterpiece of Middle-Earth. I would utterly refuse to view any such film, and would advise all aquaintances to do the same.4. The vast amount of anger that could be stirred up in me over this not a pleasant thing for me or anyone else. It is not the right of anyone except one of the children (namely Christopher) to produce any such tale for the public.Each of these is based on the former, and as I think the production of a fourth film to be a very unlikely thing, all of my statements are hopefully worthless in reality.Iarwain

06-20-2003, 08:33 PM	#43
Iarwain Pugnaciously Primordial Paradox Join Date: Sep 2002 Location: Birnham Wood Posts: 800	Presuming that a fourth film whose story takes place after the War of the Ring will be produced, these are my thoughts:<P>1. If they make a fourth film, I believe it's plot will circulate around the Dagor Dagorath. <P>2. The tale of the Dagor Dagorath was not written by Tolkien. This leaves it to be invented by three people that I do not consider at all to be trustworthy in creating a new installment for the tale of middle earth.<P>3. I cringe at the thought of PJ, Philly, and Franny ruining a fine possibility for an ending to the masterpiece of Middle-Earth. I would utterly refuse to view any such film, and would advise all aquaintances to do the same.<P>4. The vast amount of anger that could be stirred up in me over this not a pleasant thing for me or anyone else. It is not the right of anyone except one of the children (namely Christopher) to produce any such tale for the public.<P>Each of these is based on the former, and as I think the production of a fourth film to be a very unlikely thing, all of my statements are hopefully worthless in reality.<P>Iarwain __________________ "And what are oaths but words we say to God?"