[willkill4food]

<BLOCKQUOTE>quote:<HR> quote:<BR>--------------------------------------------------------------------------------<BR> I just want to know if we had never seen, heard of, or knew the name of Bill the Pony, then why does PJ have them leave the pony behind at the gates of Moria...a waste or precious seonds...we could of seen the full end of Isildur but instead we are stuck with a Pony we have never heard of...<BR>--------------------------------------------------------------------------------<P>If PJ had left out Bill, then trust me, many more fans of Bill would be angered. Why would we want to see the “full end of Isildur”? What else would you want to see beyond what the EE showed us?<BR><HR></BLOCKQUOTE><P>I didnt realize that Bill the Pony had such a loyal following, I just considered him a pony...*runs from Bill the Pony fanclub*....but still, we are talking about two different audicences, first you talk about not wanting to confuse or anger the general audience, and now you dont want to anger the loyal fans...you cant play both sides...either you add things to make the Tolkien fans happy, or you dumb it down for the general audience...so either Bill the Pony stays for the Tolkien fans and confuses the general audience, or he goes and people make posts online saying "Where is Bill?"...and about Isildur's "full" end, I just want what was in the EE to have made it into the Theatrical edition, as I think it adds some effect to how people see the Ring...<P>-willkill