[HCIsland]

I would like to add a few.<P>When Denethor tells Faramir that he should have sent him. That is, I wish you were the one that was dead.<P>When Gollum almost backs away from taking Sam and Frodo to Shelob and when he returns Sam treats him like dirt, pushing the Smeagol half down forever.<P>Frodo living without the Ring in the Shire. There's one scene where Sam finds him fingering the Evenstar given to him by Arwen. I know this can be interpretted in different ways, but to me it seems like he's fingering an absent ring. This may only be my interpretation, but I think at the end Frodo should seem almost hollow. It should be heart breaking.<P>Sam returning to Elanor. Man, I better bring Klenex.<P>And of course: Grey Havens.