[The Saucepan Man]

I don't think that the film improves on the book. But, being a visual medium, it is able to develop on some of the events and themes that are there in the text. The portrayal of Gollum and, in particular, the argument between Smeagol and Gollum is an excellent example.<P>Another theme that the film brings out well is the pure horror and brutality of war. The battle scenes at Helms Deep portray this weel, but even more so the lead up to the battle. The scenes where the youngsters and old men are being given armour, weapons and basic training are excellent. They convey such a moving sense of foreboding and dread. To think that these poor people are just about to be pitched into such an utterly horrific situation. The looks of fear on their faces just say it all.