[Joy]

Though I agree that having Arwen put a sword to Aragorn's throat and the line about a Ranger caught off guard was way off, I think that having her there is plausible.<P>When she calls for the waters of the Misty Mountains to come, we she it happen in real time. She knew that this is what she was going to do, so that is why they have her say "If you want him, come and claim him." <P>If I was the producer, I would have had Glorfindel come and give his horse to Frodo. Then have Frodo say his lines, "By Elbereth and Lùthien the Fair, you will have neither the Ring nor me!" <P>Then cut to Rivendell, have Elrond and Gandalf there. Elrod calls for the water to come, then cut back to Bruien.<P>As for Arwen, have the lines the same with Aragorn, for they are in the apendix.