To GollumsPrecious:<BR> Most of the comments you presented are true statements that, I think, no one in this thread would disagree with. I believe that this forum was begun with the idea that we could critique the movie without comparing the movie to the book; at least it was my intention that we take a look at the movie's intrinsic qualities. <BR> Indeed, if we began a forum to complain about how the movie was different from the book, we would never finish the task and it would be quite uninteresting. I too at times succumb to the desire to draw attention to the discrepancies, but my intention in starting this thread was not so.<P>P.S. Eowyn, no one has insulted anyone's intelligence for at least a week or so.<p>[ January 02, 2002: Message edited by: Rhudladion ]
|