Oh Kuruharan! You are opening a Pandora's box - but an interesting one nonetheless. What constitutes 'canonicity' in Tolkien's writings is a little like the Medieval Schoolmen's debate as to how many angels could dance on the end of a pin! I fear it will be 'pistols at dawn' for many warring members. At this point I don't enter the lists to debate canonicity, but it is an area that I know causes flames to rise that would put to shame those of Mount Doom!
__________________
I have not fed my readers with straw, neither will I be confuted with stubble
|