Fingolfin was probably called mighty at some point (as were his sons and many others besides), but I don't recall him being called mightiest. I just happen to believe that Feanor would win in a fight. If I'm remembering the quote correctly, I believe Feanor was said to have been "the greatest in power of both mind and body".
Quote:
|
but I still think that Fëanor wouldn't have helped the eventual outcome much if he had survived the Dagor-nuin-Giliath.
|
I'm willing to accept that opinion, after all, there's no way of knowing for sure.