Oh yes, I notice every single review and love them all. *cough* Texxy, I believe that person was. And there is no "Movie LotR" section, just for the book. He ought to have flamed some of the Mary-Sue type things.
If you'd like, the Mithril Awards were just held for LotR fanfiction
Here. A lot of them look adult, and they actually had an award for slash fics ( [img]smilies/mad.gif[/img] ) but some of them might be worth looking into.