The Barrow-Downs Discussion Forum - View Single Post - Ponderings about the fates of the Noldor, Galadriel and what it all meant.

drigel · 05-21-2003, 08:32 AM

Cazoz what a great thread! This is exactly the reason I have spent many countless hours wasting valuable work time on this site hehe
well a 10 meg connection sure beats my dial up at home ...

I agree with all of Mandarials points as well. She is the beautifull, mysterious connection to the glorious and tragic past of ME.

All i would add is that this thread should be forwarded to PJ for the "perfect" theme of a possible script for the Silm. Since he is probably doing The Hobbit, which we all know is going to make New Line a bucket of money, Silm would be the next natural step (and the most challenging to put on the screen admittedly). You can argue Kate Blanchette as the right choice all you want, but I for one can hear her narration throughout the movie as the underlying thread that moves through the story. Not as active as she was in TLOTR, but the only surviving "player" from the 1st age.

05-21-2003, 08:32 AM	#11
drigel Ghost Prince of Cardolan Join Date: Dec 2002 Location: commonplace city Posts: 518	Cazoz what a great thread! This is exactly the reason I have spent many countless hours wasting valuable work time on this site hehe well a 10 meg connection sure beats my dial up at home ... I agree with all of Mandarials points as well. She is the beautifull, mysterious connection to the glorious and tragic past of ME. All i would add is that this thread should be forwarded to PJ for the "perfect" theme of a possible script for the Silm. Since he is probably doing The Hobbit, which we all know is going to make New Line a bucket of money, Silm would be the next natural step (and the most challenging to put on the screen admittedly). You can argue Kate Blanchette as the right choice all you want, but I for one can hear her narration throughout the movie as the underlying thread that moves through the story. Not as active as she was in TLOTR, but the only surviving "player" from the 1st age.