![]() |
Bet you haven't seen this topic coming...
According to the Silmarillion there are a few things that the Valar haven't forseen, things in each age that do not 'arise from the past' or some such thing I mistily recall. What are these events? I'm guessing the love between Beren and Luthien and maybe the attack on the lamps because they seemed completly unprepared for that, maybe the destruction of Numenor aswell.
|
I'm right in the middle of Morgoth's Ring, so I'd say Miriel's death in Valinor, for one. It caused not only a big hullaballoo amongst the Valar, but forced JRRT to outline the rules for death and marriage for the Elves.
|
Does this mean that if they haven't forseen these events, they can't forsee events that lead on from it? Like for example, couldn't forsee Miriels death therefore couldn't forsee Feanor's revolt or couldn't forsee destruction of Numenor so couldn't see creation of Gondor and Arnor. If that is true then there forseight isn't very impressive...
|
Quote:
Quote:
Of course on the point of foresight, Mandos should probably be distinguished from his brethren as he "knows all things that shall be, save only those that lie still in the freedom of Iluvatar" (Silm., Valaquenta) I guess in answering the question of what are the things that the Valar can't foresee, a useful starting point is determining what things take Mandos by surprise/seem outside his knowledge. I think that the Beren/Luthien situation that you cite is a good example of this. Earendil's fate (and that of Elwing and their sons) may be another. |
I think the main point was in the "freedom of Ilúvatar", meaning simply that there are some things that are lined, you know, "logically" and for Valar (maybe even from some Wise among Elves or Men) they can be expected from what happens before. You know, something like it is logical that if A leads to B, then when A happens in the history, we will expect B to happen (of course, this is just a very simple scheme, the knowledge of Valar is of course transcending the simple logic of Elves or Men, but they probably also have some sort of "logic"). But there are things that are totally unexpected and can emerge "against logic", because they come from Eru's freedom. For example, I think the most obvious event like this is the emergence of hobbits.
|
Quote:
Quote:
|
Quote:
Quote:
|
Quote:
Quote:
|
All times are GMT -6. The time now is 04:30 PM. |
Powered by vBulletin® Version 3.8.9 Beta 4
Copyright ©2000 - 2025, vBulletin Solutions, Inc.