Compliment... or not?
At Bilbo's party, he says:
Quote:
The second breath of the sentence can be taken in two ways. Bilbo could be saying that most of the Hobbits he knows, he likes the correct amount or is being generous in how much the likes them. Or he is saying that there are some that he doesn't like as much as he should. So, to put it graphically: M = majority, m = minority Bilbo likes M >= what's fair OR Bilbo likes m < what's fair OR (if you want to stretch your brain.) Bilbo likes M >= what's fair > Bilbo likes m So, what do you think it is: Compliment, not a compliment, or both at the same time? |
Because I saw the movie first and Ian Holm says it a certain way I've always assumed it was a clever put down. But now that I examine it, the phrase could very well be a nice compliment!
Another thing no one will ever know. |
When I was reading that I always read it as a compliment, though I see how it could be read otherwise. I read it as they disearved more than he could give them, and while he couldn't know them well enough to like them enough, he realized they disearved more.
|
I think it's probably meant to be taken both ways. The first part being a compliment, the secon, not to be. But, as Aina said:
Quote:
|
I think it's a compliment cleverly disguised as an insult. Maybe Bilbo was hoping that only the cleverest ones (the ones most worthy of his compliments) would understand that.
|
Quote:
|
Quote:
|
To me, in the first half of the statement he is expressing regret that he hasn't got to know some people as much as he would have liked. In the second half, he is saying how there are some in the crowd, but by no means all, who he thinks might have deserved to be more highly esteemed by him.
It's a compliment all round. A very English and veiled one at that. ;) It's also one of my favourite sayings and I have long been waiting for a chance to use it, though I think it's possibly too well-known to use it in my work; maybe if I had won the lottery and was not afraid of getting the sack... :p |
I think it was both at once.
Sort of "If the shoe fits" principle. |
I love that line! But I think it was a compliment that was ill-executed..
Dont think otherwise if you havent partaken any of the beer from the Golden Perch! |
Quote:
And seeing how the anti-compliment is directed towards more hobbits(more than half, at least), I'd say that it was almost meant to be more of a demeanor than compliment. :p |
As Kuruharan said, I think. It could be taken as either a compliment or an insult, depending on who you were. I think Sackville-Baggins's should have taken it as an insult, whereas, say, the Bolgers might have taken it as a compliment, although I've now idea what sort of terms Bilbo was with the Bolgers.
But, as several others have said already, compliment or no, I like that line a lot. Though, yes, it is far too overused and well known to use in real life. -- Folwren |
I think it's a compliment, if a rather convoluted one. I was so happy to see this line in the movie; Ian Holm gives it perfectly, and the looks on the faces of the hobbits! :D
|
I've always thought of it as a compliment- and an apology. Bilbo is admitting that he hasn't made the effort to know them as well as he should, and he admits that they would have been worth knowing.
And being Bilbo, he does it in such a way as to completely befuddle them, as I'm sure he intended. |
All times are GMT -6. The time now is 10:44 PM. |
Powered by vBulletin® Version 3.8.9 Beta 4
Copyright ©2000 - 2024, vBulletin Solutions, Inc.