What was the best extended scene in the three EE's?
 

As a companion to the "What was the best new scene in the three EE's" thread, this thread asks which extended scene was best in the three EE's. That is, which scene that was originally in the theatrical edition but extended in the EE's was the best?

No question for me on this one (though, again, I still haven't seen ROTK EE). It's gotta be the scene in TTT EE where Faramir captures Frodo and Sam. The extension completely changes the scene and gives a lot more depth and feeling to Faramir's character. There is no scene that I more fervently wish would have been included in the theatrical version.

Opinions, please!

My favorite was in the TT (this might be the one you were talking about above, im not sure) when Boromir retakes Osgiliath and it shows the interaction between Boromir, Faramir and Denethor. I really thought that was a great scene

I really liked the extended Council of Elrond. It was neat to see the sky cloud over, just like it was supposed to, when Gandalf spoke the Black Speech. I love it!

I would have to say that one of my favorite extended scenes would be the one in the TT, where they show a flashback to Osgiliath with Boromir, Faramir, and Denethor. It gave me a better understanding of Boromir's character, and portrayed him in a way that made him less a "villan" in the end when he tries to take the ring from Frodo. It also aloud the audience to see the brotherly dynamic between Boromir and Faramir, which we do not get to see first hand, even in the books.

Yes, one of my favorites!
I also liked the Houses of Healing in RotK EE.

Nim:D

I think my favorite extended scene is what Merry said to Aragorn when he was watching Pippen and Gandalf ride away to Gondor.

Ooo, I loved that one too, Durbelethwen! I guess I don't have a favorite. :rolleyes:

Ohh, I don't think I could pick just one. I really liked the scene in FOTR where Sam and Frodo got to see the elves in the Shire, although I know it's not really totally accurate to the books, it really shows off the elves. For some reason, I really like the lighting and the way they shot that scene, it just seems really beautiful.

From ROTK there was this one shot of the white tree that, again, is not true to the book, but should have been left in, simply for it's cinimatic greatness. I think the camera is following Denethor and Faramir on their way to the tombs, and Denethor is going off about how there is no hope and it is better to die now rather then later, the camera pulls back to show that there is a single flower blossoming on the White Tree. It is so powerfull, I think that it adds hope to a otherwise depressing movie.

I like the scenes in Fotr when Bilbos talking about the shire in his book.A hobbit is about to kiss another Hobbit then some cupcakes go by and he grabs one of those, and the guy who cant get the "stuff" off his ear,and an old hobbit slaps a pigs "bum" to get it moving.I thought that was pretty funny.

one that springs to mind is the new scenes with Faramir and Denethor, where D calls F a 'wizard's pupil' which is a great line from the book. the reason I raise it here, is becuase I think I've seen some of the best acting in the movies in this scene from john noble, where he paraphrases the great line (to Gandalf in the book) the look on his face as he delivers these lines is priceless. you can see how he is already tempted by the Ring, and as Gandalf says, shows us what it would do to his mind, even though it would be locked away in the depths of the mountain.......

I believe, looking back on the 3 films, the acting from john noble in this scene is (perhaps) the Best of All.

That is a great scene, Essex (and well acted). In my opinion, John Noble was one of the better actors in RotK, to bad his character was twisted to such a degree. :confused:

Oh, absolutely one of the best (besides the numerous drinking songs) was Faramir talking to Pippin, when he gives him his childhood armor. Too bad they didn't tell you in the Rohan camp that Merry was wearing Theoden's childhood armor.
GASP maybe that's why they made it Faramir's armor... *hmm*


Engaging the Improbability Drive... now! {Hopefully the Phantom will pop up in my room...}

I know a lot of people don't like Eowyn's song at Theodred's funeral but I think this is the most haunting scene of the films. A definite thumbs-up for me.

Ah, very good catch, Eomer! Yes, that one rates quite high.

Also Eomer's grief over Eowyn at Pelennor.

EomerSame here, definately a timeless moment that looked and sounded perfect. I also loved Aragorns coronation song, and the Elves singing and passing Westwards through the Shire in the Fellowship was beautifully melancholic and haunting.
mark12_30I agree, a powerful and superbly captured scene.