He is going by the official rules of the Quiz Room, which I cannot find. We need one of those FAQ threads that stays at the top for the Quiz Room that states all this.

The quiz room rules were pretty much just made up as we went along...which makes it difficult for new comers. Another reason to have a MOD for this room.

Well, I'll go with the one posted by Tulkas and say that Finrod was the only one to not see Glaurung.

Lindo is correct! Sorry for all the confusion, but I thought that after a week, then anyone could continue. So its your turn then Lindolirion.

I just noticed one of mine from the first page that no one answered. Here it is:

Farmer Maggot
Elfhelm
Gloin
Gandalf
Saruman

Gloin is the only one who has never spoken with Sam.

Close, but no pipeweed.

Am I close in that it was about Gloin or Sam?

Close in the fact that someone in that list has not spoken with someone else.

Elfhelm is the only one who has never spoken with Frodo.

That's it!

Old Man Willow
Huron
Barrow-wight
Black Rider
Cave Troll

Barrow-Wight. The rest aren't site mods! [img]smilies/tongue.gif[/img]

LOL, nope that isn't it.

Huron was the only one not in Lord of the Rings?

Erm...What or Who is Huron?

Huron: A tree getting entish. They help Rohan during the Battle of Helm´s Deep

My guesses:
Cave troll, becaúse it´s the only the whole fellowship meets together.
or:
Huron, because it helps "the good guys"
or:
Old Man Willow because there´s only one of it´s kind.

[ January 02, 2003: Message edited by: Manardariel ]

Ahhh you mean Huorns.

I am so sorry for this, but I got the movie and the book mixed up. I am sticking with what's in the book, so I have to amend my list...
Old Man Willow
Huorn (thank you Beren87)
Barrow-Wight
Orc-Cheiftain
Black rider

But all guesses so far are not what I am looking for. Keep trying!

*bump*
clue-all but one have to do with hobbit(s)

Hourn cause it was the only thing that a hobbit never saw.

Wait, Merry and Pip saw Huorns...

Huorn, because it never apperently "killed" a hobbit?

[ January 16, 2003: Message edited by: Manardariel ]

A Huorn because it was the only one Frodo didn't see?

Huoron cause it never attacked a hobbit (no, that's not a changed version of that other post at alll, I mean the one:

Yes, findorfin, thats three games I've seen you simply restate someone else's answer. If you don't have anything constructive to add, then don't post. Thats in truth just spam.

Excuse me, are you talking to me?

if so, I haven't redone anyones answer thank you very much!
I said a precise answer where others have been vague, whats the matter with that.

Here, you said "killed" which was just reiterating "attacked".

On the "Who am I..." thread, my post was in essence "Frodo following the phial of Galadriel in Shelob's Lair." And RIGHT after that you posted "I agree, Frodo following the light of Elendil."

Those are the SAME thing! You don't get credit for answering correctly by agreeing with me, so what was the point in doing so?

If you read back then it wasn't actually me who wrote that, take a look before you criticise.

And on the other topic I wasn't trying to take the point, I was just supporting, sorry, I won't do it again!!

Actually, that was me...... sorry.

Now now, no need to get "hasty" findorfin.

And actually that was Manardariel, not you elentari.

Now lets get back! Can we ahve a hint please?

So, anyways...

Back to the trivia. Has anybody got it yet hobbitlass?

Thank you, Pallando, for the reminder.
This is a tough call for me. The answer I was looking for was Huorn- because it was the only thing that did not attack Frodo.
ElantariGreenleaf said huorn because 1) hobbit never saw it (not correct) but 2)it never attacked a hobbit.
Manardariel said that huorn never killed a hobbit.
TheRealFindorfin said that Frodo never saw one.
I'm going to give it to ElantariGreenleaf. Your turn.

Ok. what doesn't belong?

Bob
Nob
Butterbur
Fatty

Barliman Butterbur is the only one who is not a Hobbit?

fatty because he is theonly hobbit

Fatty is the only one who doesn't work at the Prancing Pony.

Saucepan Man you are right, but it wasn't what I had in mind.

Lindolirian you are correct! Fatty was the only one not to work in the inn.

Merry Brandybuck
Thorongil
Tuor
Ulmo
Hamfast Gamgee
Prince Imrahil
Elendil

Ulmo bvecause hes the only Valar

Such a looong list...

Elendil maybe? since he was the only one to die fighting forces/