Nope

Smeagal

No

Faramir

No. It's about a character at a particular moment in his life.

Gandalf? When Frodo offers him the ring, he's afraid to take it?

Nope.

Eowyn in the houses of healing about Faramir's love

Good guess, but it's not what I had in mind

Hint: that particular moment in the character's life is not in LOTR.

is it in the Sil? if it is Im out

No, not the Sil.

It sounds like Frodo to me...

Close but no

Bilbo's reluctance to hand over the Arkenstone?

Oh dear. You got the character, but not the situation...

Okay, I'll give it to you!

(what I had in mind actually was Bilbo at the beggining of his quest, when he's torn between his Took side and his Baggins side.)

10 days rule
 

Anyone who can come up with one can go!

Here's a super easy one to get this thing going again: (geez, three posts in a row by me...)

That fits someone we know to a T...lol! So who is it?
(Stratovarius, Chasing Shadows)

Gollum?

That fits him too, but it fits someone else better...the 'T' part was a hint! ;)

Turin Turambar?

Yes, he's the one.

Treat us to some Beatles classic, SPM, or whatever else you desire! ;)

Ten days rule...
 

Should be fairly obvious...

Erm, hroom hoom. Sorry for forgetting this one. I was trying to find some lyrics that did not relate to Frodo, Gollum, the Ring, Aragorn/Arwen, Faramir/Eowyn or Turin Turambar. Took so long that I forgot to come back ... :rolleyes:

Anyway, is it Frodo to the Ring?

Saucy's got it!

Why thank you, Elennar. :)

Next up:

Have you seen your brother, baby, standing in the shadow
Have you had another baby, standing in the shadow
I was just passing the time
I’m all alone, won’t you give all your sympathy to mine
(Have you seen your mother baby - The Rolling Stones)

Who might have said this - and to whom?

Hello?
 

I thought that this one would be rather easy.

Any takers?

Just a guess, but...Boromir?

Nope, not him.

Is it Faramir then?

No. Not him neither.

Brandir to Nienor?

I was actually thinking of Glaurung to Nienor, but Brandir fits the last two lines better.

So you're up next Evisse. :)

Thanks.
So it's me again....(I'm thinking of advertising this thread following the example of a couple of worthy Downers ;) ).

Ok, here's a cool line:

"I'm so far away that each step I take is on my way home..."
(Bon Jovi, Bed of roses).

For some reason that makes me think of Beren, though Frodo is perhaps the more obvious potential answer.

(is that cheating? if it is, I'm very sorry)

It's not cheating since it's neither of them. ;)

As a hint: this person is even further away from 'home' as these two, and is very nostalgic about it...

Could it be Bilbo in The Hobbit?

Not him either.

Perhaps it is Feanor when returning to Middle Earth?

Nope, but you're getting really close! Now think Third Age.

Here is a guess; Gandalf? Talking about going to Middle Earth, or perhaps returning to Valinor?