If Ang isn't Glorfindel, then who is? I have yet to see a counter reveal.

I think the more important part is why would he have fake-revealed now. It wasn't necessary. Seriously.

The ranger's only chance to give us another Day is a save and thus laying low. (and it would have been for the hunter even more!!!)

But if they manage to organise a double lynch then the ranger can do nothing about it.

We're trying to warn you. IT'S A TRAP!!!!!!!

No, the ranger could have and should have countered a fake reveal. Otherwise she might have been lynched herself as there aren't that many options. I trust Angu.

And we has to vote..

Sally's posting makes me feel better about her. If she was a wolf she would know more... or be kind of more aware of what's going on.

Which leads me to wonder about Nog again.

What if phantom is actually telling the truth?

Grr couldn't they just lynch Nerwen or Greenie and be done with it?

*shakes head*

Whatever phantom is, he's doing a good job at it.

I'm going to brush my teeth.

Remember, lynching an innocent toDay (not the hunter!!!) is the thing the wolves crave for. Then it would be one choice the coming Night going right and victory.

I don't know how crafty those wolves are, but they could come up with a false reveal to either flush the real one (being confident they could outspeak the opposing arguments if there was a duel of rangers) or to encourage the feeling that the gifteds should come fore thus luring their most dangerous enemy, the hunter, out in the open...

And really, as the hunter was lured out in the open, the ranger is now our only hope as it seems clear the wolves lynch whomever they wish (like they have done basically everyDay - D2 included). We need the Nightkill barred and it doesn't exactly help if you declare yourself.



It might actually be, that some of the odd-loking gaming over there is now the baddies already readying things for the Night. They are confident enough they can lynch an innocent toDay so they have already started playing against the ranger to make her/him puzzled?

I'm not sure, but the way I see it explains most of the posts made while any other explanation I have come up with falls short by a mile...

Me too..spooky

And what would that gain her/him? S/he'd know that the three wolves + one cobbler (at least one) would be on her/him immediately. How could s/he counter 4 votes against her/him?

Just asking.

If the ranger wishes to really try to buy one more Day, s/he needs to barr a kill-attempt.

I don't think I buy Phantom's reveal. I find it incredibly difficult to see Elra of all people faking a Hunter reveal - I don't think she's ever been gifted before, she's rather new, and I just can't see it happening.

Unless Phantom's pulling a bluff of some kind - make Boro the Wolf/Cobbler think that Phantom is a Cobbler while Phantom really is the Seer who's dreamt of Boro - which could be why Phantom isn't pushing an Elra lynch as much.

I'm not here. I'm disapearing until Sunday in about ten minutes. But I thought I may as well comment while I could.

I do not trust tp's reveal. Why would the Seer dream of Glirdan? Surely tp knows how easy it is to spot a Glirdwolf. :rolleyes:

I don't think I'm going to vote. I don't have the time to look over either thread carefully, and there's too much at stake to vote randomly.

EDIT: xed with a Mith, a Nog, and a Shasta

THIS THIS THIS!

Nerwen is in for an interesting hour...

Three people had already left.

Ahaha! :D

DON'T PROTECT HIM, ANGUIREL!!!!

YES, YES, LYNCH GREENIE! SHE DESERVES IT!

From my perspective I'm pretty sure she's true and it seems to me that she's more likely going to target a baddie than an innocent.

YOU'RE NOT GETTING IT.

Because she's the most suspicious girl?

So now we're getting to this.

Nog I probably gotta believe you. Even you have made more sense than him. :rolleyes: :p

THE LIVING VOTES
Boro - phantom
Glirdan - Boro
Green - sally

THE DEAD VOTES
Lommy - Anguirel -> ?

Who we should vote for in order not to deliver false information:
A Little Green
Nerwen
the phantom
Anguirel

I don't like the options. But I also don't like what will happen if we make them think Nessa was a wolf.

So a double lynch with an innocent and a cobbler = immediate wolf-win!

I do agree tp makes a nice storyline there about his "dreams" (well, what would you except from him if not that?), but see also the nice work with including Ang and Boro - who have been more than hinting to him toDay they're the wolves!

So that's it then? They want to end it toDay!

the phantom calls for lynching enough people (see the request for if the hunter can change her target), some will suspect his reveal but enough will vote for Elron who gets mad, takes tp with her and end of the game!

And see how he's bringing once more the "consoling possibility" there being only two wolves left! *how I'd love to be there to stand up against their trickery!*

I love Nerwen's defiance!

Nog who do you think is the real Glorfindel then if not Angu?

I am voting now because I'm not sure how long I'm going to be here (might as well stay till the deadline but I'm just really tired). I might retract if need be, but this is the way I'd rather the lynch went right now.

++GLIRDAN

THE LIVING VOTES
Boro - phantom
Glirdan - Boro
Green - sally

THE DEAD VOTES
Lommy - Anguirel -> ?
Agan - Glirdan -> Boro

I'm afraid it will not be a close run toDay so it might be just "whatever" we vote for.

But if it is going to be tight, I'd suggest Nerwen as she's the only one able to resist the chauvinist-gang doing their tricks with little "girlsies" (like they are messing with Elron). Just see how she bit back to Ang who very confidently tried to charm her by just being this great guy (one more sign of his guilt).

Ahaha! :D:D

:----D

THE LIVING VOTES
Boro - phantom
Glirdan - Boro
Green - sally
ed - phantom 2

Left: phantom, Angu, Nerwen, sally

THE DEAD VOTES
Lommy - Anguirel -> ?
Agan - Glirdan -> Boro

Hmm.

Whoops I just realised I voted for someone who, if getting the double vote, will signal Nessa was a wolf. Not that it probably matters much... I'm afraid we won't have a new day.

That is just Australian woman meets alumnus of Ang's alma mater... lol

Nerwen would be my first choice. Her sarcasm upon arrival might also tell about her being it. And her being away most of the Day would explain why she hasn't yet said anything about it - and if she is the ranger, she would think for a moment now what to do - while trying to find out what has been happening (if she needs to pick it up now). But that remains to be seen.

One possibility is Greenie. She has played low profile, is intelligent enough to lay low and has had no chance to react to the latest developements... Although the problem is that I think Ang "revealed" before she went away. Thus making it a bit unbelievable.

Glirdan might be a better choice: he has been overtly active, protecting and helpful as well and voted "right" - and if I'm not wrong (haven't checked) has been away long enough to have missed the reveal? Now that should have to be checked actually...

Hard to say.

THE LIVING VOTES
Boro - phantom
Glirdan - Boro
Green - sally
ed - phantom 2
sally - ed
Angu - ed

Left: phantom, Nerwen

THE DEAD VOTES
Lommy - Anguirel -> ed
Agan - Glirdan -> Boro

NO ONE VOTE FOR ANGUIREL HERE.

No that doesn't make enough sense... Angu might be being led but I'm going to trust Occam's razor nonetheless.

Have we decided Elra shouldn't die, then?

She's hunting the phantom who can't be anything more than a cobbler. We need a wolf, or just a cobbler. Not both.

I mean, between Phantom and Elra there's at least one baddie... but if Phantom is just a cobbler.... but what if he's not... and...

My head hurts.

Then wouldn't it make sense to put the double vote on someone like Boro?

Phantom won't vote for Boro, and unless Nerwen does it'll be a tie if we put the double on Glirdan or it won't matter.

It's working!
They're so good they actually deserve to win... :rolleyes:

If phantom votes for ed she'll have 3, if Nerwen too she'll have 4. If Nerwen votes for phantom it's 3-3. If she votes for Boro, it's 3-2. In which case Boro must have the double vote.

I don't think sally is a wolf.

If ed is a wolf I'm seriously going to kill her.

One of Elra and Boro is a baddie, they're competing Hunter claims, the smart thing is to keep Elra alive so she can hunt Boro tomorrow (or vice versa).

I think taking Phantom out by himself makes the most sense.

++elrond's daughter

I'm afraid Elron is the hunter indeed and I know phantom is the cobbler - who has sent messages the whole Day with Ang and Boro.

THE LIVING VOTES
Boro - phantom
Glirdan - Boro
Green - sally
ed - phantom 2
sally - ed
Angu - ed
Nerwen - ed 3

Left: phantom

THE DEAD VOTES
Lommy - Anguirel -> ed
Agan - Glirdan -> Boro
Shasta - ed -> phantom

UGH! YOU NEVER LET THE PHANTOM HAVE THE LAST WORD! NEVER!

Nerwen, darling, I love you but what are you thinking...

Dear phantom, couldn't you vote for someone like... Boro?