Was any of the Fellowship involved?

Object? No
Living? No
Event? No
First Age? No
Third Age? Yes
Idea? No
Place? No

Story? No
Song? No
Statement? No
Was any of the Fellowship involved? In a way

Was a hobbit involved?

Tangible?

Object? No
Living? No
Event? No
First Age? No
Third Age? Yes
Idea? No
Place? No
Story? No
Song? No
Statement? No
Was any of the Fellowship involved? In a way

Was a hobbit involved? No
Tangible? Yes

Natural phenomenon? (Like rain, snow...)

Object? No
Living? No
Event? No
First Age? No
Third Age? Yes
Idea? No
Place? No
Story? No
Song? No
Statement? No
Was any of the Fellowship involved? In a way
Was a hobbit involved? No
Tangible? Yes

Natural phenomenon? (Like rain, snow...) No

Hmm ...
 

Undead?

Was a dwarf involved?

In Middle-earth?

Leave it to Saucy...
 

Object? No
Living? No
Event? No
First Age? No
Third Age? Yes
Idea? No
Place? No
Story? No
Song? No
Statement? No
Was any of the Fellowship involved? In a way
Was a hobbit involved? No
Tangible? Yes
Natural phenomenon? (Like rain, snow...) No

Undead? Yes
Was a dwarf involved? In a way
In Middle-earth? Yes

I'll go for the obvious ...
 

The Witch-king?

Object? No
Living? No
Event? No
First Age? No
Third Age? Yes
Idea? No
Place? No
Story? No
Song? No
Statement? No
Was any of the Fellowship involved? In a way
Was a hobbit involved? No
Tangible? Yes
Natural phenomenon? (Like rain, snow...) No
Undead? Yes
Was a dwarf involved? In a way
In Middle-earth? Yes

The Witch-king? Nope

The King of the Dead Men of Dunharrow?

That's the one! (I didn't think it would be very hard once y'all figured out what category he was in...) Good job, Lindo!

Third Age?

living?

Place?

Thank you!
 

I have to give credit to SpM because I never would have gotten it with out that "undead" clue.
Third Age? Yes
Living? No
Place? No

Object?

Event?

First Age?

Third Age? Yes
Living? No
Place? No
Object? No
Event? Yes
First Age? Yes

Interesting...
 

Did it happen east of the Blue Mountains?

Was it a battle?

Interesting indeed...
 

Third Age? Yes
Living? No
Place? No
Object? No
Event? Yes
First Age? Yes
Did it happen east of the Blue Mountains? I don't see why not... Yes
Was it a battle? No

Did it take place above Middle-earth?

Any violence involved?

Is it one long drawn out event (as opposed to something that happens regularly and repeatedly like the sun rising in the morning)?

Third Age? Yes
Living? No
Place? No
Object? No
Event? Yes
First Age? Yes
Did it happen east of the Blue Mountains? Yes
Was it a battle? No
Did it take place above Middle-earth? No
Any violence involved? None that I know of, but there could have been
Is it one long drawn out event? No

Was any member of the Fellowship involved in some way?

Third Age? Yes
Living? No
Place? No
Object? No
Event? Yes
First Age? Yes
Did it happen east of the Blue Mountains? Yes
Was it a battle? No
Did it take place above Middle-earth? No
Any violence involved? No
Is it one long drawn out event? No
Was any member of the Fellowship involved in some way? Yes

Did it happen only a limited number of times?

Third Age? Yes
Living? No
Place? No
Object? No
Event? Yes
First Age? Yes
Did it happen east of the Blue Mountains? Yes
Was it a battle? No
Did it take place above Middle-earth? No
Any violence involved? No
Is it one long drawn out event? No
Was any member of the Fellowship involved in some way? Yes
Did it happen only a limited number of times? No

Does it happen regularly? Is it a holiday?

Is it the standing silence?

Was there a specific event that caused the event to start happening?

Is it related to the moon?

did it originate in Beleriand? Undying Lands?

Does it happen in Valinor?

Third Age? Yes
Living? No
Place? No
Object? No
Event? Yes
First Age? Yes
Did it happen east of the Blue Mountains? Yes
Was it a battle? No
Did it take place above Middle-earth? No
Any violence involved? No
Is it one long drawn out event? No
Was any member of the Fellowship involved in some way? Yes
Did it happen only a limited number of times? No
Does it happen regularly? Is it a holiday? Yes and yes
Is it the standing silence? No
Was there a specific event that caused the event to start happening? Yes
Is it related to the moon? Yes
Did it originate in Beleriand? Undying Lands? No and no
Does it happen in Valinor? Not exactly