Ta-Daa!
Mithalwen has it :)
It is indeed the old green hood and cloak that Dwalin loaned Bilbo; kept afterwards in a trunk at Bag-End.

Your turn :)

Oh wow, this is exciting.... fire away :)

Third Age?

Yes

Living?

Unique?

Object?

Proper name?

An artificial structure?

Third Age Yes
Living No
Unique No
Object Yes
Proper name No
Artificial structure - errr...

Built by a Dwarf?

Built/made by elves?

Third Age Yes
Living No
Unique No
Object Yes
Proper name No
Artificial structure - errr... no?
Built by a dwarf No

Any more? :D

A natural object?

Third Age Yes
Living No
Unique No
Object Yes
Proper name No
Artificial structure - errr... no?
Built by a dwarf No
A natural object No

Used by a man?

Third Age? Yes
Living No?
Unique No?
Object Yes?
Proper name No?
Artificial structure - errr... no?
Built by a dwarf? No
A natural object? No
Used by a Man? Yes

Used by a man of Gondor? Or Rohan?

Yes
Third Age? Yes
Living No?
Unique No?
Object Yes?
Proper name No?
Artificial structure - errr... no?
Built by a dwarf? No
A natural object? No
Used by a Man? Yes

Used in battle?

And, I assume due to cross-posting based on times, you missed Eruanna's question, post #3412.

Oh thanks Fire foot : I did indeed


Third Age? Yes
Living No?
Unique No?
Object Yes?
Proper name No?
Artificial structure - errr... no?
Built by a dwarf? No
A natural object? No
Used by a Man? Yes
Used by a man of Gondor? Or Rohan? Yes
Built/made by elves? No*
Used in battle? Yes

* Indicates not known as fact but can reasonably be assumed to be the case on balance of probability, and if it isn't right then it is not material.

Used at the Battle of Pelennor Fields?

Used at the battle of Helm's Deep?

Is it a weapon?

Built/made by orcs?

So sorry, I tried to answer these using the internet phone at Waterloo station last night.. clearly it did not work... :o

Third Age? Yes
Living No?
Unique No?
Object Yes?
Proper name No?
Artificial structure - errr... no?
Built by a dwarf? No
A natural object? No
Used by a Man? Yes
Used by a man of Gondor? Or Rohan? Yes
Built/made by elves? No*
Used in battle? Yes
Used at the Battle of Pelennor Fields? Yes
Used at the battle of Helm's Deep? No
Is it a weapon? No
Built/made by orcs? No

Used for defense?

Third Age? Yes
Living No?
Unique No?
Object Yes?
Proper name No?
Artificial structure - errr... no?
Built by a dwarf? No
A natural object? No
Used by a Man? Yes
Used by a man of Gondor? Or Rohan? Yes
Built/made by elves? No*
Used in battle? Yes
Used at the Battle of Pelennor Fields? Yes
Used at the battle of Helm's Deep? No
Is it a weapon? No
Built/made by orcs? No
Used for defence? Yes

Éowyn's shield?

Is it a shield?

Third Age? Yes
Living No?
Unique No?
Object Yes?
Proper name No?
Artificial structure - errr... no?
Built by a dwarf? No
A natural object? No
Used by a Man? Yes
Used by a man of Gondor? Or Rohan? Yes
Built/made by elves? No*
Used in battle? Yes
Used at the Battle of Pelennor Fields? Yes
Used at the battle of Helm's Deep? No
Is it a weapon? No
Built/made by orcs? No
Used for defence? Yes
Is it a shield? No

Made by man?

A helmet?

Third Age? Yes
Living No?
Unique No?
Object Yes?
Proper name No?
Artificial structure - errr... no?
Built by a dwarf? No
A natural object? No
Used by a Man? Yes
Used by a man of Gondor? Or Rohan? Yes
Built/made by elves? No*
Used in battle? Yes
Used at the Battle of Pelennor Fields? Yes
Used at the battle of Helm's Deep? No
Is it a weapon? No
Built/made by orcs? No
Used for defence? Yes
Is it a shield? No


Made by man? Yes
A helmet? No

Well that is the 20 gone..... ;)

The City Gate of Gondor?

The City Gate of Gondor? Nope

Was it exclusively defensive, or offensive as well?
:rolleyes: How about a "yes or no" Q:
Used for offense?

Is it used to protect a specific individual?

Crafted in Second age?

Can it be worn?
Is it an armour?

Is it smaller than a door?