The Barrow-Downs Discussion Forum

The Barrow-Downs Discussion Forum (http://forum.barrowdowns.com/index.php)
-   Middle-earth Mirth (http://forum.barrowdowns.com/forumdisplay.php?f=24)
-   -   WWJ I: A New Saga, A New Beginning... Or Is IT!?!?!? (http://forum.barrowdowns.com/showthread.php?t=12273)

Bergil 10-11-2005 04:23 PM

I'm rolling thunder, I'm pouring rain.
I'm coming on like a hurricane
white lightning flashing across the sky
you're only young but you're gonna die


As soon as I was told I would be a wolf, I was going to own up (starting whith this song) if it became clear I was toast, but then I found out the games ended at 10:30. just so you know, there was no logic to anything I said, I was trying to lay as many trails as possible, leading anywhere, so my death would confuse you beyond recovery. It didn't work. nothing left to say but see you next game!

edit: darn, the next game's full

Sleepy Ranger 10-11-2005 04:53 PM

Quote:

edit: darn, the next game's full
It is? Where? I didn't know they picked a mod yet...

Eonwe 10-11-2005 05:45 PM

malkatoj pretty much correct on our reasoning. night one, we wanted fea to be alive because we thought there was a good chance of her being lynched, the way she was acting. looking back though, i think it was a bad idea to kill kitanna. she always seemed like the kind that wasn't too vindicative. a better choice would have been someone like sleepy ranger or hiriel.

night two was jack. pretty obvious, thought she was the seer, like malkatoj said.

night three. TORE. i thought that this was the most important target. i was wrong. fea, i swear, if you had guarded him, i would have torn my hair out. i still figured he was the ranger, adn thought that he prolly had fea protected, because he would think that i would go for her. i had it all planned out; you both knew the same number of innocents (this was acctually not ture, i think) so i figured id best go with sure kill, cause the ranger couldn't protect himself. glirdan would have died laughing if fea had protected TORE, because i sent him a number of frantic pm's to see if the ranger could protect himself. it really would have been ironic, in a way...

night four. fea was teh obvious choice. get rid of that dratted woman! argggghhhh!

night five. sigh.....it never came, i was cut down in my prime....

anyway, that was what i was thinking throughout the game. like i've said, great game you all, hope to see you in another sometime!

Sleepy Ranger 10-11-2005 06:11 PM

A question to Eonwe or any other wolf,
Who did you plan as your next victim? (Perhaps if no lynching had taken place, who would you have killed?)

Bergil 10-11-2005 06:15 PM

I dont know, but the next WWJ game isn't full or even planned. I saw them discussing time-zones and assumed wrong.

Eonwe 10-11-2005 06:23 PM

um, i don't know. if i had survived teh night, i would have considered hiriel again. i suspected he was the hunter, and killing him would be a two for one deal. but i would ahve to see if he suspeted me (ie was likely to target me!). if not him, sr would have been a candidate, but prolly not, casuse i would have seemed like i killed him cuase he attacked me (which would ahve been the case! :D ). if not sr, there was always jack to fall back on...so yeah one of those three. but it would depend largely on how the game was shaping up.

ps. it really sucked. i had to work monday morning. i think if i had been home, i could have at least swayed one (maybe thin, i don't konw.) oh well!

pss. sr, did you realy miss count, or did you just do that to shore up your accusations? and was anyone at least a little swayed by my last post. :confused: i thought it was a rather good defense...i guess not...ohwell.

Sleepy Ranger 10-11-2005 06:26 PM

On your vote? Yea I messed up the count, silly me... :rolleyes:

The Perky Ent 10-11-2005 07:02 PM

~*~ Don't Forget ~*~


Since the game is now over, you no longer need to turn your hiding on so people can't view you. Feel free to turn it off! Not that I'm saying I really want you to...or that if you don't I'll make your deaths in WW anything but quick and painless ;)

Feanor of the Peredhil 10-11-2005 07:53 PM

I know the feeling about being worked to death. Between basic Uni requirements *cough going to classes and doing homework* and going home for the weekend, I was a bit busy.

I have a feeling that if I'd had more sit-down time, I wouldn't have thrown so many plot holes into the mix, I'd have caught on more about TORE, and our plan might have succeeded. On the other hand, if I'd had more time, I would have made enough a case against Sleepy to have killed him, and that's certainly not a good thing. Especially with his vindictive light-sabering skills.

Glirdan 10-11-2005 08:14 PM

To Eonwe, malkatoj and Bergil. Just a little info. If I'm correct, Hiriel chose each of you to take down at Night, Bergil on Night 2, malkatoj on Night 3 and Eonwe on Night 4. I find that slightly wierd yet really funny. Now if I'm right, Fea decided to protect Eonwe on one of the Nights. Creepy!!!!

As for WWJ II, nothing has been planned or started planning. We're still deciding on the mod, who will most likely be malkatoj if Perky has no complaints. Then Perky can mod WWJ III. Sound good?

Gurthang 10-11-2005 10:06 PM

Quote:

Originally Posted by Gurthang
I would believe, however, that the wolves would kill someone who did not directly have contact with them either way. This would leave absolutely no trail. So:

Voted for Kitanna:
Gurthang

Mentioned by Kitanna:
Eonwe
Wayne
Gurthang
Thinlómien
Folwren
Feanor


Mentioned Kitanna:
Feanor
Rune
Folwren
Gurthang
Hiriel


(I think that's everyone. Please tell me if I missed someone.)

Those not on any of the above lists:

Bergil
Malkatoj
Sleepy Ranger
TOREstel


And on that sketchy evidence I am suspicious of them. But only slightly. I'm watching you. :p

Also, I don't like people who don't vote. You know who you are. :mad:


Quote:

Originally Posted by malkatoj
NIGHT two:
We killed Kitanna, obviously. The reasons for this were exactly as you picked up on that DAY--she didn't accuse any of us, none of us really mentioned her, it would leave no trail. It put you back at DAY one, with no idea what to do. We were tempted to kill either Fea or TORE, but we figured they would both work to our advantage, if thought innocent. Also, we "knew" Fea would be protected...wrong there. Our reasoning basically worked--none of you seemed to *really* suspect that Bergil was a wolf until he died.

Wow, I had no idea I was that close. Pretty lucky that I had two wolves down on Day 2. Ironic how that exact post was also used against me by TOREstel. :p

The Only Real Estel 10-13-2005 07:54 PM

looking back
 
I couldn't help but laugh on DAY one when Fea said these two bits concerning me:

Quote:

My recommendation is to kill TOREstel
(a "random and factless suspicion" you might say)

Quote:

since I'd rather accidentally be lynched than accidentally lynch the seer, I won't act on my random and factless suspicions...
It was almost as if she knew my role! :eek:

Feanor of the Peredhil 10-13-2005 09:15 PM

Quote:

Originally Posted by The Only Real Estel
It was almost as if she knew my role! :eek:

Purely coincidental. :) My random suspicion was, amusingly enough, Bergil.

Glirdan 10-14-2005 02:49 PM

Thanks to these peeps!!
 
I'd like to thank the following people in this game.

SpM - You helped me start the WWJ game with a few ideas. Thanks a ton friend!!

'Mer - You gave me a few pointers through PM's as well. Thanks. And if it wasn't you, than it was Boro. For the life of me, I can't remember whom it was!! :rolleyes:

Perky - You were a great backup mod my friend!! When you're modding WWJ III, sign me up immedeately to play. I loved your deaths. Thanks a ton for being backup mod and for coming up with the name.

Bergil - First Wolf to be gone and first Wolf I picked (completely random by the way). You did a pretty good job, even if you did only last two Days. Thanks for joining. Besides, you deserved another chance after being so wrongfully lynched in WW IX. Sorry about that.

malka - Second Wolf to get the lynch. You played the game really well for a newbie. Thanks for playing. Can't wait to see what deaths you come up with in the game. Have fun with it.

Eonwe - My last Wolf. You did really well, especially when you voted for Bergil which gave (I believe) the deciding lynch. I really thought that would have thrown the villagers off, but I was wrong. Good game.

Folwren and Gurthang - I'm glad you guys accepted my invitation to join. Thanks for making the game even more interesting. Folwren, good job in making it to the end. Gurthang, tis a pitty you were lynched like that, but I was rather fond of your death, especially since I myself play instruments. Hope you guys had fun.

Fea - Glad you accepted the invite to. Especially since someone else would have been the Ranger and I believe that no one could play a better Ranger in this game then you did. Congrats!!

TORE - First person to sign up who's experienced. Glad you did at that. You played a really good Seer. Your death was the one I was most fond of, after mine of course. :p

Wayne - I'm sure you would have made a good Cobbler. To bad you got lynched on the first Day before you could show your stuff.

Kitanna - Second person who signed up who's experienced. To bad those Wolves got you on Night 2. Seems like that's happened in each game that I've been in with you. Sorry about me attacking you in WW IX by the way..

Thin - Good job making it to the end. You did really good. Not sure if I invited you, but if I did, thanks for joining. If not, thanks for playing anyway.

Sleepy - I liked that idea of having a picture of werewolf you had. To bad we couldn't put it in. I suggest you do that in one you're going to mod. Good job in making it to the end.

Rune - Not much I can say except good job in making it to the end my friend. Hope you had fun.

Hiriel - I'm surprised you made it that long. Good job. Loved you as the Hunter. Good game.

Spectaters - Glad you all decided to watch. Hope you enjoyed it.

Wilwa, Mith, Oddy and others I forgot - Thanks for repping me. It means a lot coming from you three and all those else who weren't in the game.

And I have one final thing. Sorry that the start time was so late. It's because I only have a two hour limit on the computer and my parents normally go to bed at ten and me at eleven, so I decided to start it at an in between point. Sorry if it was an inconvienience(sp?) for any of you. Hope you all had fun!! I know I did!!! ;)

Thinlómien 10-24-2005 09:23 AM

Quote:

Thin - Good job making it to the end. You did really good. Not sure if I invited you, but if I did, thanks for joining. If not, thanks for playing anyway.
Hmm... You didn't invite me. The thing you thought that you had invited me made me a bit curious. Where did you get that from? :) Well, thanks (again, for the thousandth time) for the great modding you did, Glirdan.

Feanor of the Peredhil 10-24-2005 10:12 AM

Quote:

Originally Posted by Glirdan
To Eonwe, malkatoj and Bergil. Just a little info. If I'm correct, Hiriel chose each of you to take down at Night, Bergil on Night 2, malkatoj on Night 3 and Eonwe on Night 4. I find that slightly wierd yet really funny. Now if I'm right, Fea decided to protect Eonwe on one of the Nights. Creepy!!!!

Creepy? No... hilariously ironic. I protected Eonwe the night I changed my mind about TORE. :D What a horrible decision, that. But oh so amusing in hind-sight.

Glirdan 10-24-2005 02:59 PM

Quote:

Hmm... You didn't invite me. The thing you thought that you had invited me made me a bit curious. Where did you get that from? Well, thanks (again, for the thousandth time) for the great modding you did, Glirdan.
Forgive me Thin. I was just checking. I wasn't sure who I invited, but now that you told me that I didn't invite you, I know everyone I invited. Thanks for the that!! :D

Quote:

Creepy? No... hilariously ironic. I protected Eonwe the night I changed my mind about TORE. What a horrible decision, that. But oh so amusing in hind-sight
Yes it is ironic, but also slitghtly creepy on my end, yet hilariously funny when I got the PM's from you guys. Very amusing!! :D

wilwarin538 10-24-2005 03:29 PM

In the game I modded, both the hunter and the ranger chose all three wolves at some point. :rolleyes: It was very amusing for me. :p

Thinlómien 10-25-2005 05:58 AM

Quote:

Forgive me Thin. I was just checking. I wasn't sure who I invited, but now that you told me that I didn't invite you, I know everyone I invited. Thanks for the that!!
Forgive??? May you tell me what's there to forgive? (Whatever it is, it's okay with me :))
I'm actually quite flattered that you thought you had invited me :D


All times are GMT -6. The time now is 02:36 AM.

Powered by vBulletin® Version 3.8.9 Beta 4
Copyright ©2000 - 2025, vBulletin Solutions, Inc.