made of stone? Yes
owned by a hobbit? No
Mentioned in LotR? Yes

Does it have a specific name?

Is it the stone that Pippin threw in the well in Moria?

... or the stone that Boromir threw in the lake before the Moria Gate?

Mentioned in other books, too?

Owned by anyone at all?

Used for a greater purpose?

Does it have a specific name? No
Is it the stone that Pippin threw in the well in Moria? No
... or the stone that Boromir threw in the lake before the Moria Gate? No
Mentioned in other books, too? No (Not that I know of)
Owned by anyone at all? No
Used for a greater purpose? Meaning what?

I think my answers to Menel's questions may have been slightly misleading - maybe I should say he could attempt those things but may have slight difficulties due to weight, size, etc...

Did it come in contact with any of the Fellowship?

Is it warding the country of Gondor through the Anduin?

Did it come in contact with any of the Fellowship? No
Is it warding the country of Gondor through the Anduin? No

*salute, duck, slash (aka Aragorn technique) at Menel*
 

Hm... in the past 15 questions Menel is the only one to have gotten a 'yes' answer, and both of them involve hurting Nilpaurion. Is this a problem? Yes

No, wait. It's not my turn. :rolleyes:

Is it a building?

Is it a natural feature?

Was it ever moved?

Is it located west of the Misty Mountains?

Can one person carry it?

Is it a building? No
Is it a natural feature? No
Was it ever moved? In a way
Is it located west of the Misty Mountains? No
Can one person carry it? No

Is it located in Gondor?

Is it mentioned more than once?

Is it located in Gondor? No
Is it mentioned more than once? Yes

BTW, I love your new sig!

let's get the geographical issues out of the way
 

Is it located east of the Misty Mountains?
Or south of the Misty Mountains?

About the sig - Thanks! I have my mother to thank for it, she says the most hilarious things sometimes... :D

is it possibal to be moved by people?

Is it located east of the Misty Mountains? Yes
Or south of the Misty Mountains? Yes
is it possibal to be moved by people? In a way

East of Anduin?

Used for a greater purpose basically means a small thing realted to a big thing, my thinking was a white stone used for Minas Tirith, and i take it was you that gave me the bad rep... i don't see why it was a bad question?

:eek: No, it wasn't me who gave you a bad rep! I don't think it was a bad question, just a little unclear. I understand now, though.

Used for a greater purpose? No
East of Anduin? Yes

located on an island?

well i wouldn't mind to know who gave me a bad rep, they didn't leave their name, which they should if they give bad reps... myself i leave g.g. for when i give a rep...


anyways


On a Mountain?

A Wag.
 

The Black Gate?

Is it in Mordor?

located on an island? No
On a Mountain? Yes
The Black Gate? No
Is it in Mordor? No

firefoot, you mind giving the past anwsers...thanks

Is it the secret door in the Lonely Mountain which led to Smaug's lair?

You're kidding, right?
 

Event? No
Living? No
Objekt? Yes
Limited Quanity if Object? Yes
Third Age? Yes
Second Age? Possibly
The Elessar? No
First Age? No
Is it a weapon? No
Can I hit Nilpaurion Felagund with it? Please? Go for it. (You can try...)
Isildur's Ring chain? No
Article of clothing? No
a piece of jewellery? No
people are envious for it? No
Is there more than one? No
a gift? No
Did an Elf own it? No
Did a Man own it? No
Did a dwarf own it? No
Is it made of wood? No
Would hitting Nilpaurion Felagund like that [over the head] have hurt a whole lot? Yes (If you could)
Made of metal? No
Made of Giftly material? No
The Stone of Erech? No
made of stone? Yes
owned by a hobbit? No
Mentioned in LotR? Yes
Does it have a specific name? No
Is it the stone that Pippin threw in the well in Moria? No
... or the stone that Boromir threw in the lake before the Moria Gate? No
Mentioned in other books, too? No (Not that I know of)
Owned by anyone at all? No
Did it come in contact with any of the Fellowship? No
Is it warding the country of Gondor through the Anduin? No
Is it a building? No
Is it a natural feature? No
Was it ever moved? In a way
Is it located west of the Misty Mountains? No
Can one person carry it? No
Is it located in Gondor? No
Is it mentioned more than once? Yes
Is it located east of the Misty Mountains? Yes
Or south of the Misty Mountains? Yes
is it possibal to be moved by people? In a way
Used for a greater purpose? No
East of Anduin? Yes
located on an island? No
On a Mountain? Yes
The Black Gate? No
Is it in Mordor? No

And the new question:

Is it the secret door in the Lonely Mountain which led to Smaug's lair? No

Is it the trolls BIlbo met, after they were turned to stone?

Is it on the Lonely Mountain?

Is it the trolls BIlbo met, after they were turned to stone? No
Is it on the Lonely Mountain? No

;)

Is it located in the Mountains of Mordor?

Return of the King?(third book)

Is it located in the Mountains of Mordor? Meaning any of the mountains surrounding Mordor? Yes.
Return of the King?(third book) Yes

Doh! I forgot the south of the Misty Mountains thing. Then again, I took "not in Mordor" to encompass the Mountains around it.

Is it a Tower?

Saucepan - I thought about that... and then went for technicalities. ;)

Is it a Tower? No

Does anybody live there?

Is it also mentioned in TTT?

is it a pass? (as in Cirith Ungol)