Was it sang by a member of the Erebor company? No
The Goblins' song Fifteen birds...? No

super duper blind shot
 

was it the trolls song? if any?

was it the trolls song? if any? No (I don't think there was one)

thats what i thought


Was it sang in a tavern?

Was it sang in a tavern? Nope

Did Bilbo sing it?


Is it a campfire song in the Hobbit?

*Now comes with The Hobbit by his side*
 

Was it sang in Rivendell?


Was it sung after death of Smaug?

The Goblins' song as the captured the Dwarves and Bilbo?

4 Questions in a row, Gil? Tsk Tsk.

But Firefoot has it. It is the Goblin's song in the Misty Mountains.

The Goblins' song as the captured the Dwarves and Bilbo? Yes!

Good job, Firefoot. You're up next. :)

Here we go again....


Event?

Living?

Objekt?

Limited Quanity if Object?

Third Age?

Second Age?

Thanks, Saucepan.
 

Event? No
Living? No
Objekt? Yes
Limited Quanity if Object? Yes
Third Age? Yes
Second Age? Possibly

The Elessar?

First Age?

*defends self with shield and catapults large rock at Nilpaurion Felagund*
 

Is it a weapon?

Can I hit Nilpaurion Felagund with it? Please?

The Elessar? No
First Age? No
Is it a weapon? No
Can I hit Nilpaurion Felagund with it? Please? Go for it. :p

*fires Silmaril laser at Menel's shield*
 

You killed one more of my double! Now I only have less than a million of them!

Isildur's Ring chain?

Article of clothing?

a piece of jewellery?

people are envious for it?

Isildur's Ring chain? No
Article of clothing? No
a piece of jewellery? No
people are envious for it? No

Is there more than one?


@Nilpaurion Felagund: Where do you get that Silmaril? ;)

Is there more than one? No

a gift?

Did an Elf own it?

There's this company on Hyarmenos that manufactures hi-quality Silmaril replicates. They're quite useful for laser guns.

And no, this is not protected by your oath! You never swore to pursue with anger those who infringe the copyright of the Silmaril. :p

Besides, such a copyright would have already expired.

You know Elves . . .

a gift? No
Did an Elf own it? No

Did a Man own it?

Did a dwarf own it?

Is it made of wood?


@Nilpaurion Felagund: Nay, that's ok then. :D
(I'm doing too much RPGs :rolleyes: )

*hits Nilpaurion Felagund over the head with whatever this object is*
 

Would hitting Nilpaurion Felagund like that have hurt a whole lot?

Did a Man own it? No
Did a dwarf own it? No
Is it made of wood? No
Would hitting Nilpaurion Felagund like that [over the head] have hurt a whole lot? Yes

Hm... in the past 15 questions Menel is the only one to have gotten a 'yes' answer, and both of them involve hurting Nilpaurion. Is this a problem?

Made of metal?

I'm not complaining...


Made of Giftly material?

Made of metal? No
Made of Giftly material? No

A shot in the semi-darkness ...
 

The Stone of Erech?

Too dark as of yet...
 

The Stone of Erech? No

made of stone?

owned by a hobbit?

Mentioned in LotR?