The bookcase Bilbo gave away on his 111th birthday? Yes

Now how'd you get that so fast? ;)

Third Age?

Because I'm supercool? :smokin:

Third Age? Yes

2000 posts!!! :D:D

First Age?

First Age? Yes

Living?

Living? No

Grats on 2000, is it a place?

Is it an item?

Congrats on 2,000! 2/5th of the way to beatin Pio ;)

Does it have to do with water?

Is it an event?

Firefoot, with your water question, are you serious, asking me what I was thinking, or just mocking me?

Grats on 2000, is it a place? No
Is it an item? Yes
Does it have to do with water? No
Is it an event? No

Thanks Bombadil and Perks. :)

Dangerous in anyway?

Was it owned by a member of the Fellowship?

Dangerous in anyway? Yes
Was it owned by a member of the Fellowship? No

Is it a weapon?

Aiglos?

Is it a weapon? No
Aiglos? No

Was it owned by more than one person?

Is it Orcrist?

Was it owned by more than one person? No
Is it Orcrist? No

Perks, how about checking my answers? I said it's not a weapon. ;)

An article of clothing (including jewellery)?

Is it some kind of armor?

Does it belong to an Elf?

Was it used as a weapon?

Is it some kind of armor? No
Does it belong to an Elf? No
Was it used as a weapon? No

Does anyone own it?

Does anyone own it? No

Arkenstone?

Arkenstone? No

Was it made by craft? Or does it exist in nature?

Is it made of stone?

was it made by elves??

NK, you forgot this.
 

An article of clothing (including jewellery)?

Was it made by craft? No
Or does it exist in nature? Yes
Is it made of stone? No
was it made by elves?? No
An article of clothing (including jewellery)? No

Sorry about that, Nil.

Is it a star or constellation?

Is it one of a kind?

Is it a star or constellation? No
Is it one of a kind? Yes

Does it have a name?

Is it a sort of plant?